This is a common question that I’m asked directly by readers of the blog and that I see pop up from time to time in Facebook groups about Mexico.
Judging by the comments on Facebook, the consensus among tourists and expats is that the answer is a firm “no” and that it’s only a bluff by a corrupt cop to get a bribe. That prevailing belief leads to some very interesting recommendations from fellow group members that vary from refusing to handover your license to carrying a stack of laminated copies of your license in your glove box.
Many of the recommendations, if followed, could land you a starring role in a future episode of Locked Up Abroad. I may address some of those in a future post, but for now, let’s just answer the million dollar question that appears in the title.
Can the Police Lawfully Keep My License Until I Pay a Traffic Ticket?
It depends on the jurisdiction. Many states and municipalities have sections in their traffic laws that authorize officers to seize and retain the violator’s driver’s license, registration card and/or license plate to guarantee that payment is made.
That means it really comes down to where you are stopped and who stops you (federal, state or municipal).
A Real-Life Example
This particular post was inspired by a reader who wrote to tell me that a transit officer in Cancun had stopped her husband for supposedly speeding. The officer told him that he was going to issue a citation and that his license would be retained until he went to the station to pay it the next day. The reader questioned the legality of seizing the license, and well, here we are.
Cancun is located in the municipality of Benito Juarez. Article 178 of Benito Juarez’s Traffic Regulations (Reglamento de Tránsito para el Municipio de Benito Juárez, Quintana Roo) specifically authorizes the seizure of the license as a guarantee:
Artículo 178.- Tratándose de vehículos con placas de circulación de otros países, entidades federativas o del Estado de Quintana Roo, los policías de tránsito podrán retener al infractor como garantía del pago sobre las infracciones cometidas al presente Reglamento, considerando el orden siguiente de acuerdo a lo que tenga disponible:
I.- La licencia para conducir o permiso provisional para conducir vigente, según sea el caso;
II.- La tarjeta de circulación;
III.- Las placas de circulación, y en caso, cuando el vehículo se encuentre estacionado en lugar
prohibido, y no se encuentre el conductor o el propietario del vehículo o estando presentes, uno
u otro, no muevan voluntariamente el vehículo; y
IV.- El vehículo.
I could keep listing similar laws for other Mexican municipalities, but I think you get the point.
By the way, there are 2,448 municipalities in Mexico, so please refrain from asking me in the comments section about the laws for different ones. You guys will just have to research those on your own.
Let’s Wrap This Up
When you think about it, it makes sense. How else would the local governments ever compel people, especially a foreigner with a foreign license, to pay his or her traffic fines?
The problem is that some corrupt cops use this as leverage to encourage foreigners to pay a bribe to avoid returning for their license the next day. This sort of thing happens with greater frequency when tourists are driving back to the airport to fly out.